Importance and complexity of evidence on impact

An interesting article on the Nesta blog by Patrick Taylor this week got me thinking about measuring the impact of service design projects. This is a subject that keeps coming up in our field, but that has not been tackled yet. Maybe we can learn from lateral fields such as social innovation. It seems that a lot of good work is being done there in this respect.

In the article Patrick reflects on his involvement in developing and applying an intelligent approach to evidence gathering on the impact of funded social innovation projects. He described how they set up a 6 steps process, and how he applied it on a series of projects. He then reflects on his key learnings from this process. For me the 5th and last one stood out. Here Patrick explains that the identification of evidence needs to be done from 4 different perspectives: the delivery organisations, the funders, the researchers, and the policy makers. He states that while many people may have the experience and background to do the evaluation from more than one of these perspectives, hardly anyone can be realistically expected to cover all four of them. As he states that “there are no geniuses in the world of impact”. He makes a plea for humility and interdisciplinary empathy, while applying and further developing joint standards.

Patrick’s considered arguments match very well with the similar situation we often find ourselves in in the service design field. Also there a strong need is often expressed for more evidence-based reflections on the impact of our work, and likewise it would be impossible for one person or party to cover this from the perspectives of all the key stakeholders involved. A peer review based way of doing validations, combined with a mutually agreed set of guidelines, or standards as Nesta calls it, would be beneficial.

How to not become (too) cynical

As design researchers at STBY we are dealing with lots of complex issues and data. We are diving into root causes, problem areas and, luckily, also…

Where do you live on Dollar Street?

Are you bamboozled by the daily pandemic statistics of your country? Or have you even tuned out? These numbers are designed to be super clear, and…

Beyond Human Centred Design

COVID19 has given the world the time to rest, and the opportunity for us to rethink the way we live. It has also revealed how inseparable we are with…

Let’s Talk Maps and Mapping

Interested in mapping services, ecosystems, stakeholders and beyond? Join us as we explore how other disciplines approach mapping and what we can take away as design researchers and service designers.

The Subspecies of Design Researcher

As a design research agency, STBY has worked with design researchers of many shapes and sizes. While the role of ‘design researcher’ becomes more common and recognised as a formal position in many different types of organisations, it’s worth reflecting on how we all work and the unique skills and attitudes needed in different settings.